Knotenhirn vs. Basic Memory
As of 28 October 2026
Basic Memory (Basic Memory LLC): Open-source knowledge base for AI tools on Markdown files, locally or in the cloud. Knotenhirn is the shared memory for teams and their AI agents. This page shows how the two differ, with sources.
| Basic Memory | Knotenhirn | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is for | Knowledge base for AI tools on Markdown files, locally or in the cloud | shared memory for teams and their AI agents |
| AI agents read and write (MCP) | yes, official MCP server; local, the cloud also offers access via MCP | yes, hosted MCP server, sign-in via OAuth with Microsoft or Google |
| AI submits proposals, people approve | partly: the write tools save directly; in the cloud the AI can instead leave comments and suggested edits on notes that take effect only once accepted | yes: the AI submits many notes as proposals that a person accepts, edits or rejects in the browser; it saves single notes directly |
| Permissions apply to the AI too | Owner, Editor and Viewer roles in the team; that they restrict the AI's access is not documented | yes, an agent sees only what the connected person may see |
| Organisation | knowledge graph from links and observations that the person or the AI writes into the notes | automatic: notes organise themselves into topics, plus a graph |
| Search by meaning | yes, full-text and vector search | yes, included in the price |
| History | in the cloud, versions with restore; locally via your own solutions such as Git | every change with person, channel and time; earlier versions can be restored |
| Knowledge gaps: what was asked and not found | not documented | yes, overview of agent searches without results |
| Data location | locally on the device or cloud servers in the USA | servers in Germany (Nuremberg); AI via Google Vertex AI in the EU |
| Data processing agreement | not documented | yes, as PDF |
| Setup | locally, install a Python package and set up MCP; cloud with sign-up | sign-in with Microsoft or Google, no installation |
| Price | open source free (AGPL); Team $15 per person per month paying monthly, Business $30 paying yearly | €9 per person per month or €90 per year, AI included |
Prices per month excluding VAT, in the vendor's currency. “Not documented” means the vendor does not describe the feature in its public material.
When Basic Memory is the better fit
- You want open source and your notes as Markdown files on your own computer.
- You work with Obsidian and want to share the same files with the AI.
- You want an explicitly typed knowledge graph with schemas.
When Knotenhirn is the better fit
- Notes should organise themselves into topics without anyone maintaining links and types.
- Groups should decide who and which AI sees what.
- You want to see what your agents asked for and did not find.
- You want your data in Germany and a data processing agreement.
Sources
- Basic Memory: pricing
- Basic Memory: collaborating with AI
- Basic Memory: comments and suggestions
- Basic Memory: teams
- Basic Memory: security
- Basic Memory: privacy
- Basic Memory on GitHub
All details are taken from the vendors' public pages, as of 28 October 2026. Vendors change prices and features; their current pages are what counts. Found a mistake? Write to knotenhirn@michael-schwarz.dev and we will correct it. Trademarks mentioned belong to their owners. Knotenhirn is not affiliated with Basic Memory LLC.